You are here

Emergency Room Violence Prompts Hospitals to Tighten Security

Safety requires staff involvement

As an increase in violent incidents in health care facilities spurs a host of emergency preparedness plans, hospitals looking to tighten security must recognize that emergency departments are especially vulnerable, security experts said in a Healthcare Finance News article.

In California, a bill recently approved in the state Assembly seeks to close one dangerous loophole in hospital security. Under current law in that state, anyone convicted of assaulting a physician or nurse rendering emergency medical care outside of a hospital or health care facility faces a fine of up to $2,000 and/or up to 1 year in jail. But place the same assault inside the hospital, and the same incident is treated as a lower misdemeanor, punishable by only up to 6 months in jail, the article says.

According to David LaRose, president of the International Association for Hospital Security and Safety, emergency rooms are often the top target of violence. However, behavioral health departments and facilities are another primary target.

For several years hospitals have initiated “perimeters within perimeters” –– increased security in maternity wards to protect newborns or in the pharmacy to deter the theft of drugs, LaRose told reporter David Weldon. Much of the new security attention is focused on protecting points of entry without affecting the “public openness and accessibility” mission of the hospital.

LaRose said that while security spending is going towards better locks, more security cameras, and the obvious trappings of a more secure building, the most important spending is on risk assessment and staff training.

Risk assessment requires a team approach, LaRose said. Clinicians, support staff, security professionals, and outside security experts all need to participate. However, that’s also where many hospitals fail: They don’t ask enough questions of enough people.

“Sometimes there wasn’t enough assessment done before a solution was relied upon,” LaRose said of problems he has seen. “You can’t just throw technology at something and say that’s going to fix your problem. You can’t just say that a staff member is going to fix your problem. That’s why you really have to have a collaborative, cohesive stakeholder meeting. You need to understand the workflow; you need to understand what the organization’s goals are, what the culture is, who your customer and patients are.”

While health care administrators may look for a silver bullet cure to violence in their facilities, the solution is actually very practical, said William Nesbitt, president of Security Management Services International.

“Generally, physical security really applies to things like locks, access control systems, and fencing –– actual devices and security officers. It is in fact very situational,” Nesbitt said.

“One of the first things we do when we go into any site, no matter where it is, is that we’re looking to find out what the crime environment is like,” Nesbitt said. “The threat environment is so different from one locale to another. There are sociological differences. There are ethnic differences. We look at what kind of history does the hospital have.”

But there is one thing that all hospitals and health care centers have in common when it comes to security and safety, Nesbitt said. The facility needs to be open to everyone –– just how open should depend on how each visitor is assessed from a risk perspective.

“Probably the most vulnerable is the emergency department, especially if you’re a level one trauma center,” Nesbitt said. “That’s where the sexual assault victims will be coming in, the gunshot victims, victims of other violence, people high on PCP or something, people with psychological problems.”

Training for employees is on the rise, and Nesbitt said he is encouraged that extreme acts of violence against health care workers may decline.

“One of the things that is getting better is the training programs that train people within hospitals on how to deal with adverse behavior,” Nesbitt said, which can often mean knowing how to diffuse a hostile situation before it becomes violent.

And while shootings or armed threats can prompt security overhauls, they’re not the only types of encounters that cause hospitals to seek a security provider.

“In some cases it definitely is an incident,” Nesbitt said. “In some cases it is a member of staff that starts to express feelings that they don’t feel safe.”

“It could also be property crime –– cars being broken into in the parking lot, purse snatches in the parking lot,” Nesbitt said.

But whatever the security challenge or crime, the first line of defense should be the employees themselves.

“The most important single factor in keeping the hospital safe is getting the employees involved in being the solution. That takes some training,” Nesbitt said.

Source: Healthcare Finance News; May 5, 2015

Recent Headlines

Lifesaving Life Foam for Battlefield, Terrorist Attacks, Trauma
Cell Reprogramming Process May Benefit Patients Prone to Severe Hypoglycemia
Beagles Beat Out Advanced Technology
Almost 64% of Patients Showed Decreased Hemoglobin A1c Levels
Over Half of Patients Had Reduced Pain Levels of 30% or More
Spina Bifida, Cleft Lip Among Defects Caused by Antiepilectics
Study Data Indicate Drug May Provide Complete Remission in PV
Teplizumab Slows Progression to Disease by at Least Two 2 Years
Over 25% of Study Patients Showed 6–12 Months Remission