You are here
Program to Reduce Hospital Readmissions Among Older Patients Flops in California
Researchers at the University of California–San Francisco have found that a nurse-led intervention program designed to reduce readmissions among ethnically and linguistically diverse older patients did not improve 30-day hospital readmission rates. Their findings suggest that hospitals should evaluate such programs before implementing or continuing.
Their study was published October 7 in the Annals of Internal Medicine.
“The lack of effect in this population, which was well-connected to primary care, suggests reducing readmissions is challenging,” said co-lead author L. Elizabeth Goldman, MD, MCR. “Our findings should give pause to hospitals adopting interventions shown to work in dissimilar populations and settings without evaluating their effect and should prompt consideration of alternate or additional approaches to reducing readmissions in populations with significant medical co-morbidity and language diversity.”
According to the study, as many as 30% of hospitalized elders are readmitted within 30 days, and many are preventable. Recent changes in payment models, such as the formation of accountable care organizations and the implementation of Medicare readmission penalties, have led many hospitals to initiate discharge support programs to reduce readmissions and to improve elderly patients’ transitions from the hospital to their home. Previous studies have shown these programs to have mixed success.
To learn whether intervention programs have a beneficial effect, Goldman and her colleagues studied 700 adults 55 years of age and older who spoke English, Spanish, or Chinese (Mandarin or Cantonese) in a publicly funded, urban Northern California hospital and who were being discharged to the community. This population had high rates of multiple co-morbid medical conditions and low health literacy.
From July 2010 to February 2013, the usual standard of care for discharge was compared with within-hospital, one-on-one self-management education before discharge by a dedicated language-concordant registered nurse combined with telephone follow-up by a nurse practitioner after discharge.
Based on data from area hospitals, the researchers determined the number of emergency-room visits and readmissions to those hospitals at 30, 90, and 180 days after initial hospital discharge. At 30 days, the readmission rate through the intervention program and usual care was approximately 15%, which was lower than the national average readmission rate for Medicare patients. Emergency-room visits in the intervention study may have been higher than in the usual-care group.
As a result, the researchers emphasize caution when adapting interventions used in other populations. Readmission penalties could disproportionately affect hospitals serving diverse populations, particularly if standard interventions do not work, they say.
“There has been a tremendous push nationally to adopt these hospital-based transitional-care programs, particularly ones that require few additional resources,” said senior author Margot Kushel, MD. “However, in this diverse elderly population, the intervention did not have an impact on key policy-relevant outcomes.”
Source: EurekAlert; October 7, 2014.