You are here
Can a Short Video Improve Apixaban Knowledge in an Inpatient Setting?
The development of direct oral anticoagulants (DOACs) has made anticoagulation more manageable for patients. In contrast to warfarin, these agents have more predictable pharmacological properties, require less frequent monitoring, and are less dependent on factors such as diet and concomitant medications.1 Because of the reduced complexity of DOACs compared with warfarin, the perceived need for patient education may be diminished.2
The Institute for Safe Medication Practices classifies anticoagulation therapy as high risk, as misuse is associated with a significant risk of serious injury or death.3 Furthermore, the Joint Commission’s National Patient Safety Goal 03.05.01 focuses on reducing the likelihood of patient harm associated with anticoagulation therapy.4 This goal specifically mentions the importance of comprehensive patient counseling.
Effective patient education is essential in helping patients optimize their medications.5 In patients taking apixaban (Eliquis, Bristol-Myers Squibb), a lack of understanding regarding appropriate use could lead to an increased risk of thromboembolism or bleeding. Patients taking apixaban should understand the purpose of anticoagulation therapy and how to properly take the medication, including how to handle missed doses and reduce the medication dose after a week of therapy if being treated for acute venous thromboembolism.6 Patients should also be familiar with adverse effects of the medication, including how to recognize situations that require emergency medical care.
One way of providing education is through the use of educational videos. Previous studies have demonstrated that educational videos have many benefits, including increasing patient knowledge, decreasing health professional time for patient counseling, improving disease control, and increasing patient satisfaction.7–10 Currently, there is no literature evaluating apixaban video education. The purpose of our study was to validate an apixaban educational video by measuring knowledge before and after the video.
A quasi-experimental study was conducted at St. John Hospital and Medical Center, a 772-bed community teaching hospital in Detroit, Michigan, from July 2015 to March 2016. Patients were identified via a clinical decision support system (Sentri7, Wolters Kluwer). Patients 18 to 90 years of age who were prescribed apixaban for treatment of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE), reduction of risk of recurrent DVT/PE, and prevention of stroke in nonvalvular atrial fibrillation (AFIB) were included in the study. Patients were excluded if they were diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, were pregnant, or were unable to execute study procedures. Only the first patient admission during the study period was included for analysis. Informed consent was obtained from all patients, and the study was approved through the hospital’s institutional review board.
The primary outcome of this study was the change in short-term knowledge as measured by the difference in overall scores between a pre-test and immediate post-test. Secondary outcomes of this study included evaluation of long-term knowledge retention as measured by changes in test scores after one month and evaluating if learning was dependent upon previous treatment with apixaban, previous treatment with any anticoagulant, or level of education. Level of education was evaluated by comparing those with less than high school education, those with high school education, and those with more than high school education.
Prior to study commencement, two apixaban educational videos (each approximately five minutes in length) were developed by the investigators using Camtasia (Techsmith). Separate videos were created for the treatment and prevention of DVT/PE and prevention of stroke in AFIB due to differences in dosing between indications. Two corresponding questionnaires were created to assess knowledge (
The videos are available at the following links: http://tinyurl.com/ApixabanAFIB and
Patients were approached for potential enrollment during their hospital stay. Once consent was obtained, the pre-test was administered by the study investigators. Patients then watched the apixaban video that corresponded with their prescribed indication (AFIB or DVT/PE). Patients viewed the video on a tablet computer provided by the study investigator. After the video, patients completed a post-test and a satisfaction survey. The satisfaction survey consisted of three questions that asked how much patients learned from the video, how helpful the video was, and if they would recommend watching the video to a family member. Study investigators answered any additional questions related to apixaban and provided education on knowledge deficits present after completion of the immediate post-test. The patient was given a card with a YouTube link for the video and a copy of the video on a DVD so that he or she could access it at home. After one month, patients were contacted via telephone, and the questionnaire was administered again. If patients were not reached after three attempts, they were recorded as “lost to follow-up.” Demographic data collected from patients included age, gender, education level, previous anticoagulants taken, and indication. Deidentified data were obtained from YouTube to evaluate view duration, average percent viewed, and unique views. Unique views allow views to be counted once per device so that multiple views are not counted.
The sample size was calculated using a minimal clinical difference between the pre- and immediate post-test of 17.5% with a standard deviation of 12.5%. These estimates were taken from an unpublished study evaluating a rivaroxaban video at our institution. Using a power of 90% and a two-tailed alpha of 0.05, we calculated a required sample size of eight pairs. However, to meet assumptions of the paired t-test, we planned to enroll 30 patients, and after accounting for a 10% estimated drop-out rate, our goal was a total of 33 patients. Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the study population with respect to demographic and clinical factors, as well as to describe video views. The primary outcome—score improvement on immediate post-test compared with the pre-test—was tested by the paired t-test. The change in correctness on individual questions from the pre-test to immediate post-test was analyzed using McNemar’s test. Score changes at one month were evaluated by paired t-test. Additionally, we evaluated whether the primary outcome differed for patients previously on apixaban, previously on any anticoagulants, or by level of education. This was analyzed using a mixed analysis of variance, and interactions were evaluated. All data were analyzed using SPSS VS 22.0, and a P value of 0.05 or less was used to indicate statistical significance.
Seventy patients were screened for entry into the study, and 33 patients were included (24 patients refused consent, and 13 patients were unable to complete study procedures). Reasons for being unable to complete study procedures included poor mental status (n = 5), dementia (n = 3), discharged prior to study completion (n = 2), blindness (n = 2), and medication discontinuation (n = 2). Baseline characteristics are described in
Patient scores increased from pre-test to immediate post-test by 19.7% (95% confidence interval [CI], 14.5–24.9). This improvement was not significantly different for those with an indication of AFIB versus DVT/PE (19.1% versus 22.2%; P = 0.646). Improvement in scores depended on previous apixaban or anticoagulant use (P < 0.05), but not level of education (
Scores from pre-test to one-month post-test were not significantly different (6.4% increase; 95% CI, 1.6–14.5). Four of the 22 patients said they watched the video after discharge and before the one-month follow-up. Seven of the 22 patients had been provided with additional apixaban education by a health care provider between the first visit and one-month post-test. This included education from five physicians, one pharmacist, and one nurse.
During the course of the study there were 57 unique video views for the AFIB video. The average video view percentage was 69.5%, and the average duration was 3:22. There were 18 unique views for the DVT video. The average view percentage was 62.4%, and the average duration was 3:08. On the satisfaction survey, 81.9% of patients said they learned quite a bit or a huge amount, and 97% said they found the video helpful or very helpful. Lastly, 97% of patients would recommend that another patient on apixaban watch the video.
This is the first study that has evaluated an apixaban educational video in any setting. Our study found an improvement in short-term knowledge for important clinical concepts related to apixaban use; however, this increase in knowledge was not retained at one month. Patients newly started on apixaban had a larger change in knowledge and achieved similar scores after education compared to patients with prior apixaban use. Most patients were satisfied with the video, with almost all patients indicating they would recommend this video to a family member. Our study agrees with previous studies that have evaluated short-term changes in knowledge in patients receiving anticoagulation therapy.
One study with similar methodology evaluating a 12-minute warfarin video saw an improvement in the rate of patients passing a knowledge test after the video (43% versus 90%; P < 0.001).12 While the percentage of patients who passed improved, absolute changes in scores were not reported, and there was no follow-up evaluation to measure retention of material. Another study evaluating a five-minute video on venous thromboembolism prophylaxis found improved knowledge scores after watching the video (62% versus 83%; P < 0.001).13 No follow-up evaluation of knowledge retention was completed. We could not find any previous studies that have evaluated long-term knowledge retention when evaluating videos as an intervention. However, previous research has shown that information should be repeated to patients for effective learning.14
In our study, we were disappointed that only four patients (18%) said they watched the video after discharge at our one-month follow-up. If a higher proportion of patients had revisited the videos, this may have improved longer-term knowledge retention. Although we had unique YouTube views, this data is not identifiable and may have occurred at any point during the study period, including after we contacted patients for the one-month follow-up. We attempted to increase video viewing by providing a card to patients with the YouTube link and giving patients a DVD with the video. However, this does not seem to be an effective strategy. One meta-analysis found a larger effect size for diabetes education when the intervention involved Internet and text versus text alone.15 Texting a video link could serve as a reminder to the patient to watch the video and would prevent information from being lost upon discharge.
While our study provided a tool for inpatient apixaban education, we believe that these videos would also be excellent outpatient education tools. Following study completion, we have been asked to share our video with several outpatient clinics. Additionally, we opened the videos for public viewing on YouTube. Prior studies of patient education materials available on YouTube have shown variable quality of video content.16 We believe it is important to provide patients with validated, evidenced-based videos that are publically available. Furthermore, the videos we produced are indication-specific, whereas previous anticoagulant videos have provided only an overview for all indications. Proving indication-specific videos is particularly important for apixaban, as different indications have different dosing.17
This study had limitations. First, knowledge changes were not compared to a control group; therefore, we cannot compare our results with traditional counseling from a health care provider. However, video education does not need to be a substitute for provider counseling. In fact, a meta-analysis evaluating multi-media education showed larger effects when the multimedia intervention was used as a supplement to health care provider counseling as opposed to a substitute for provider counseling.18 Second, we were able to contact only 22 of the 33 patients for the one-month knowledge assessment. While these patients were similar in age and prior apixaban use, numerically there were more patients who were new to apixaban. This may have decreased the benefit seen at the one-month follow-up because these patients demonstrated the largest improvement in immediate knowledge gain. Also, our patients may have different levels of education compared to other populations, and therefore, the results may vary at other institutions. However, changes in knowledge scores did not depend on education level, and the video was developed to teach patients at less than a high school level of education. Future studies should investigate whether additional strategies aimed at increasing video views are associated with improved long-term knowledge.
The apixaban educational video led to improvements in short-term knowledge. Patients did not retain this knowledge at one month; however, few patients reviewed the video after discharge. Future studies should seek ways to encourage patients to revisit video education or evaluate other strategies to improve long-term knowledge retention.
Figure and Tables
Degree of Knowledge Change Depends on Previous Anticoagulant or Apixaban Use
Apixaban Knowledge Questionnaire
|Construct||Question 1||Question 2|
|Medication purpose||Which disease is Eliquis (apixaban) used to treat or prevent?
||What type of medication is Eliquis (apixaban)?
|Identify adverse effects||What is a major side effect of Eliquis (apixaban)?
||Which of the following is a sign of bleeding?
|How to take the medication||How should you take Eliquis (apixaban)?
||When can Eliquis (apixaban) be stopped safely?
|Missed doses||If you miss one dose of Eliquis (apixaban), what should you do?
||Why is it important to not miss doses?
|When to seek emergency attention||When should you seek emergency attention while taking Eliquis (apixaban)?
||Which of the following situations is not a bleeding emergency?
|Over-the-counter medications||Which of the following should you tell your doctors and pharmacists about before taking Eliquis (apixaban)?
||Which of the following increases bleeding risk while taking Eliquis (apixaban)?
|Dosing differences (deep vein thrombosis only)||What is the dose of Eliquis (apixaban) for the first seven days?
||How will you take Eliquis (apixaban) after the first seven days?
|Variable||n (%) or mean (SD)|
|Age in years||69.6 (12.1)|
|Male gender||15 (45.5)|
|Previous oral anticoagulant use||20 (60.6)|
|Previous apixaban use||10 (30.3)|
|Indication||Atrial fibrillation||27 (81.8)|
|Education level||< High school||2 (6.1)|
|High school||11 (33.3)|
|Post-high school||20 (60.6)|
|Internet access||26 (78.8)|
DVT = deep vein thrombosis; PE = pulmonary embolism; SD = standard deviation.
Number and Percent Correct on Pre-test and Immediate Post-test for Individual Questions
|Construct||Q1 Pre-test n (%)||Q1 Post-test n (%)||Q2 Pre-test n (%)||Q2 Post-test n (%)|
|Medication purpose||26 (78.8)||32 (97)||0.031||30 (90.9)||32 (97)||0.625|
|Identify adverse effects||24 (72.7)||30 (90.9)||0.031||11 (33.3)||20 (60.6)||0.016|
|How to take the medication||13 (39.4)||24 (72.7)||0.003||32 (97)||32 (97)||1.00|
|Missed doses||17 (51.5)||23 (69.7)||0.146||20 (60.6)||26 (78.8)||0.07|
|When to seek emergency attention||12 (36.4)||22 (66.7)||0.002||23 (69.7)||27 (81.8)||0.219|
|Over-the-counter medications||18 (54.5)||29 (87.9)||0.01||20 (60.6)||24 (72.7)||0.219|
|Dosing differences (DVT only)||6 (100)||6 (100)||1.00||4 (66.6)||6 (100)||0.50|
DVT = deep vein thrombosis.
- Hanley CM, Kowey PR. Are the novel anticoagulants better than warfarin for patients with atrial fibrillation?. J Thorac Dis 2015;7;(2):165–171.
- Heidbuchel H, Berti D, Campos M, et al. Implementation of non-vitamin K antagonist oral anticoagulants in daily practice: the need for comprehensive education for professionals and patients. Thromb J 2015;13:22
- Institute for Safe Medication Practices. Medication self-assessment for hospitals 2011; Available at: www.ismp.org/selfassessments/Hospital/2011. Accessed July 13, 2016
- The Joint Commission. National patient safety goals 2016 Available at: www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/6/2016_NPSG_HAP.pdf. Accessed July 13, 2016
- Grime J, Blenkinsopp A, Raynor DK, et al. The role and value of written information for patients about individual medicines: a systematic review. Health Expect 2007;10;(3):286–298.
- Eliquis (apixaban) prescribing information New York, New York: Bristol-Myers Squibb. 2016;
- Superior CK, Broyles JE, Oliphant CS, et al. Development and evaluation of a medication education videotape for hospitalized patients. Am J Health Syst Pharm 2002;59;(9):859–861.
- Baldwin DM. Viewing an educational video can improve phosphorus control in patients on hemodialysis: a pilot study. Nephrol Nurs J 2013;40;(5):437–442. quiz 443
- Katz SJ, Leung S. Teaching methotrexate self-injection with a Web-based video maintains patient care while reducing health care resources: a pilot study. Rheumatol Int 2015;35;(1):93–96.
- Moore SJ, Blair EA, Steeb DR, et al. Impact of video technology on efficiency of pharmacist-provided anticoagulation counseling and patient comprehension. Ann Pharmacother 2015;49;(6):631–638.
- McGuire LC. Remembering what the doctor said: organization and adults’ memory for medical information. Exp Aging Res 1996;22;(4):403–428.
- Kim JJ, Mohammad RA, Coley KC, Donihi AC. Use of an iPad to provide warfarin video education to hospitalized patients. J Patient Saf 2015;11;(3):160–165.
- Marini BL, Funk K, Kraft MD, et al. The effects of an informational video on patient knowledge, satisfaction, and compliance with venous thromboembolism prophylaxis: a pilot study. Patient Educ Couns 2014;96;(2):264–267.
- Ley P. Satisfaction, compliance, and communication. Br J Clin Psychol 1982;21;(pt 4):241–254.
- Saffari M, Ghanizadeh G, Koenig HG. Health education via mobile text messaging for glycemic control in adults with type-2 diabetes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Prim Care Diabetes 2014;8;(4):275–285.
- Mukewar S, Mani P, Wu X, et al. YouTube and inflammatory bowel disease. J Crohns Colitis 2013;7;(5):392–402.
- Roca B, Roca M. The new oral anticoagulants: reasonable alternatives to warfarin. Cleve Clin J Med 2015;82;(12):847–854.
- Ciciriello S, Johnston RV, Osborne RH, et al. Multimedia educational interventions for consumers about prescribed and over-the-counter medications. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013;